The Community Engine Blog

News, tools, and analysis for innovating in the information economy

  • Main
  • RSS 2.0

« Work Overload | | Innovating for Value in Blog Search »

Imitation is the surest sign of success

I disagree with Jason Calacanis. IceRocket's adoption of tagging using a format invented by technorati indicates that technorati is achieving wide marketplace acceptance. By my estimates over a million bloggers are using the technorati format.

Sections:

Topics:

Today, Jason Calacanis wrote about how icerocket, a blog search engine, had added tagging support.  Jason's remarks were, typically for him lately, riding technorati a bit.

But it's how IceRocket supports tags that's the real kicker.  They're using the reltag microformat invented by Tantek Çelik, Kevin Marks, and Derek Powazek of technorati as explained on this IceRocket help page.

Some might think this news is all the more reason to question technorati's future. Technorati invents a microformat, gets it adopted, and then finds competitors eating its lunch. But the reality of it is that IceRocket's adoption of the reltag standard is the surest sign of success for at least some parts of technorati's strategy. Take into account these observations:

  • Technorati currently tracks 13 million blogs.
  • Let's say half of those are producing tags of some sort, making 6.5 million blogs tracked with tags. The tags can either be inferred using the categories from the blog's RSS feed or explicitly embedded in the posts using reltag. The estimate of 6.5 million comes from the fact that over half of all blogs are capable of at least producing categories, making them de facto taggers.
  • Kevin Marks, technorati's crawler guru, tells me that on the order of 15% to 20% of tags are currently culled using reltag with the rest coming from RSS categories.
  • Running this estimate against 6.5 million total taggers suggest that on the order of 1 to 1.3 million blogs are serious enough about tagging to explicitly use the microformat.
With this background, there are two immediate conclusions one can draw from Ice Rocket's adoption of tagging using reltag:
  • Blog post tagging is significant, with over a million explicit taggers to back that conclusion up.
  • The reltag microformat is a runaway success, based on the analysis above, and IceRocket sees no real business alternative to adopting it.

I disagree with Jason. I see IceRocket's adoption of reltag as a sign that technorati is succeeding in getting its standards accepted the market place. When a market leader is getting its standards accepted first, everyone else has to play catch up.

[update: I added some names to the inventors list for the reltag microformat per Tantek Çelik's comment]

Bud posted this on July 20, 2005

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://thecommunityengine.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/fpgibson/thecommunityengine.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/663

Comments

Thanks for the kind words Bud. To be accurate, rel="tag" was invented by Derek Powazek and Kevin Marks, both of Technorati. I was merely responsible for providing feedback, writing down the details, and editing the specification.

Posted by: Tantek at July 21, 2005 01:49 AM

Thanks for the clarification Tantek, I am amending the post.

I'm not sure whether these are kind words or merely an alternative point of view to Jason. Technorati clearly faces market challenges.

Posted by: Bud Gibson at July 21, 2005 10:27 AM

Post a comment




Remember Me?